Ply over wood blocks

Discussion in 'Subfloor Preparation' started by bournemouth, Sep 26, 2011.

  1. bournemouth

    bournemouth Super Moderator

    2,015
    766
    113
    Was round a friends house earlier and he had a flooring company round to price up for karndean ( as always good to know what others near by are charging ) and the bloke was saying his wood blocks all have to come up and be bulk filled back to original level as plywood over wood blocks will cause dry rot within 6 months and the floor will need replacing, is this true why have I never heard this before :oops: as the old company I worked for always got us to ply over wood blocks if a vinyl of some type was going down
     
  2. coolevilangel

    coolevilangel Well-Known Member

    4,299
    912
    113
    he's right.
    I wouldnt put ply over wood blocks, too many things 'could' go wrong
    Best just to rip up and start from scratch
     
  3. bournemouth

    bournemouth Super Moderator

    2,015
    766
    113
    Thanks got job I've looked at 240 sq of polysafe to go down but wood blocks down and they have had new stud walls built 2 new kitchens put in and male and female toilets built on top of wood blocks in a school and they were moaning about price already so there's no way they would pay for bulk filling with chipping, do people really pay to have all that work done ? Having just learnt this that is what I'll be pricing for from now on, thanks learn something new every day
     
  4. dazlight

    dazlight Super Moderator

    7,216
    1,709
    113
    Also mate, there properly won't be a dpm under the woodblocks. So in that case a good way to go is take up then asphalt. That way it building the height back up and it's a dpm.
     
  5. Jay

    Jay Well-Known Member

    686
    30
    0
    True the blocks will rot away and like Daz said there will be no dpm.
    Heres one though which has really got my goat up, doing a grade 2 listed barn at the moment which is going to be a vets. Had a major discusion with the guy from the herritage whos is point blank refusing to allow me to install 6mm ply for the karndean and says 4mm is all they will allow, I've tried till I'm blue in the face telling him its not what karndean recomend even showing him their installation guidlines and he still ain't havin it grrrrrrrrrrr.
     
  6. coolevilangel

    coolevilangel Well-Known Member

    4,299
    912
    113
    Jay
    Organise a site visit from your karndean rep..
    Let him explain to them the reason why 6mm is what they advise and the reason to maintain the warranty :thumbs
     
  7. Jay

    Jay Well-Known Member

    686
    30
    0
    Already tried they ain't interested, I had a battle just to get 4mm in there. Its grade 2 listed so they make the rules and they ain't budging.
    So had my sister whos a solicitor draft me up an official document for everyone to sign off on, so they all understand and theres no coming back on me.
     
  8. coolevilangel

    coolevilangel Well-Known Member

    4,299
    912
    113
    How big is the area mate?
    If it was a decent size id be telling the rep he could lose the order unless he got his arse up here and backed me up
     
  9. Jay

    Jay Well-Known Member

    686
    30
    0
    Cool its 200m2 of Davinci 16 x 16 tiles, and the rep did come out to the meeting and felt he was just banging his head against a brick wall. Its rediculous mate its their way or no way at all, they won't even let the client have feature strips or borders which is a bit of a god send makes my job easier. I mean don't get me wrong but I'll fit 4mm ply everyday of the week, but I know this is wrong should be 6mm.
    WHY IS IT WE ALWAYS SEEM TO TAKE IT IN THE ARSE FROM THE POWERS TO BE.
     
  10. coolevilangel

    coolevilangel Well-Known Member

    4,299
    912
    113
    oh well, if it goes awry then theres no warranty from karndean id bet.. :?
     
  11. Jay

    Jay Well-Known Member

    686
    30
    0
    Thats what the rep said and they don't seem to care even though the client does hence why I've made everyone including the jobs worth from the herritage sign my document if goes south then it ain't landing back in my lap.
     
  12. Matt

    Matt Well-Known Member Staff Member

    6,328
    1,402
    113
    There is nothing wrong with 4mm plywood providing the subfloor is suitable for it. Infact the subfloor for 4 and 6mm need to be at the same standard. If its not good enough for 4mm its not good enough for 6 mm either.

    The product on top is irrelevant .
     
  13. coolevilangel

    coolevilangel Well-Known Member

    4,299
    912
    113
    doesnt matter when the manufacturers state that it has to be a min 6mm ply tho matt ;)
     
  14. Matt

    Matt Well-Known Member Staff Member

    6,328
    1,402
    113

    Nope.

    Karndean have no responsibility with warranty towards subfloor defects.

    They can also not blame a subfloor that is not as recommend for a failer of there product if it is actually not to blame.
     
  15. Jay

    Jay Well-Known Member

    686
    30
    0
    Now thats completly thrown me.
     
  16. Matt

    Matt Well-Known Member Staff Member

    6,328
    1,402
    113

    :lol: 4mm is not liked as it actually follows the contours of the subfloor. If the subfloor is already flat but your installing due to floorboard joints etc then there is no problems.

    As for 6mm, it will hide cupped boards etc better but will still follow the floor if bad and is actually more prone to pop the pins out with movement.


    Problem with 4mm - 6mm plywood is that installers use it to mask poor subloors. The subfloors should be sanded first or you simply jump upto 12mm plywood but then you have height issues.
     
  17. Jay

    Jay Well-Known Member

    686
    30
    0
    DITTO. :lol:
     
  18. bladerunner

    bladerunner Well-Known Member

    1,280
    17
    38
    Forget 4mm it isnt suitable for either LVT or hardfloor that involves full stickdown.
     
  19. Matt

    Matt Well-Known Member Staff Member

    6,328
    1,402
    113

    why is that?
     
  20. bladerunner

    bladerunner Well-Known Member

    1,280
    17
    38
    So many installers have had probs with the basic ply ie not enough surface area to anchor it down.I have the new theory that we should be using 9mm instead of 6mm for the extra few quid needed to justify the rolls royce of a better installation just walk on it to enhance acoustics etc(for me anyway).
     

Share This Page