?

Herringbone - Laminate vs Engineered vs Solid

  1. Laminate

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  2. Engineered

    14.3%
  3. Solid

    14.3%
  4. LVT

    71.4%
Multiple votes are allowed.

Herringbone - Laminate vs Engineered vs Solid

Discussion in 'Wood' started by Ghettosmurf, Jan 26, 2018.

  1. Ghettosmurf

    Ghettosmurf New Member

    2
    0
    1
    Hi all,

    Bit of a flooring noob here, so hopefully you can steer me in the right direction!
    We're looking at picking the floor and fitter for our new build in the next while. The boss has decided she want herringbone in the downstairs hall, sitting room and kitchen.
    As the title suggests, I'm just wondering what people's thoughts are on the type of flooring.
    While price is a factor, if the poeople think solid wood is the way to go then we'll be able to manage it somehow (beans on toast from now until we move in)

    From what I've read the advantage of laminate would be that it's usually harder-wearing, easier to clean, little maintenance and cheaper.
    I was talking to one fitter and said he'd be reluctant to recommend a laminate herringbone as it looks more artificial (when compared to plank laminate) and because there are a large number of joints, it can lead to issues (especially in a kitchen where there are heavy appliances, furniture etc.) even when its been fitted correctly (quality underlay and expansion)

    Is there truth in that?

    How long would you expect a laminate to last based on the use case above?
    I know the solid/engineered wood is more susceptible to impact damage, staining and scratches etc. so would probably need to be sanded and resealed every 3 (?) years or so?
    If the laminate could last 8 (?) years would it make more sense to just to go with that and replace when required instead of needing to sand and refinish a solid/engineered floor as well as having to worry about any wine spills etc.?

    Given the choice what would you advise?

    Thanks!
     
  2. dazlight

    dazlight Super Moderator

    6,865
    1,620
    113
    For me Karndean parquet would be the best. That is a LVT ( luxury vinyl tile )

    If going for a laminate I’d say get quickstep impressive as water proof and can take a bashing.

    Buy I do like Engineered as well :)
     
  3. Spacey

    Spacey Super Moderator Staff Member

    6,516
    1,878
    113
    Have you looked at LVT
    It’s low maintenance Doesn’t require sanding or treatments and is naturally warmer and quieter than wood or laminate and many come with very long ware guarantees some up to 35 years
     
  4. Ghettosmurf

    Ghettosmurf New Member

    2
    0
    1
    Up until 5 minutes ago I never really considered it - seems like its advanced quite a bit.
    I'll drop into a showroom or two tomorrow and check it out.

    Is it quite obvious its not wood?
     
  5. dazlight

    dazlight Super Moderator

    6,865
    1,620
    113
    Some look amazing now. Research some of these LVT Parquet

    Karndean art select
    Distinctive
    Moduleo
    Project floors.

    I’ll put a few pics up for you
     
  6. Spacey

    Spacey Super Moderator Staff Member

    6,516
    1,878
    113
    New Amtico Form Parquet has some great colours in the range Really nice product
     
  7. Dan2223245

    Dan2223245 Active Member

    43
    7
    8
    Spacia does parquet. Only came out recently.
    Same price as plank fitting some this week looks great.
    Sierra also does a nice herringbone only 2 colours but good value.
     
  8. dazlight

    dazlight Super Moderator

    6,865
    1,620
    113
    Not seen the Spacia parquet. I have seen the Amtico form one. Not used it.
     
  9. Spacey

    Spacey Super Moderator Staff Member

    6,516
    1,878
    113
    You mean Form not Spacia

    If my customers want parquet LVT and nothing from produced samples catches their eyes
    Then I can offer anything they like from any manufacturer in either wood or stone in any available colour or colours and any size they want wether its Pleated herringbone, chevron herringbone, double herringbone, two colour double T herringbone ect ect..,
    That’s the joy of LVT
    The possibilities are limitless
    If They want it they can have it
     
  10. Dan2223245

    Dan2223245 Active Member

    43
    7
    8
    No spacia do parquet too. Have the samples in the shop.
    Fitting sunbleached oak this week.
    Come in large or small plank off the shelf.
    They launched 10 colours or so in December.

    Priced up a van Gough job in herringbone the cutting charge was eye watering.

    And unbeveled parquet doesn't look great.
     
  11. Spacey

    Spacey Super Moderator Staff Member

    6,516
    1,878
    113
    I cut everything my self and bevel
    it’s cheaper for me an the customer

    And no never seen Spacia parquet Only Form
     
  12. merit

    merit Well-Known Member

    8,003
    1,640
    113
    I’m not a massive fan of the herringbone laminate, the joins are not great. If you don’t like the plastic look you get from laminate be carful of going down the LvT route. Some of them can look a bit artificial especially when the light reflect of them. Depending on the type of finish you may not be able to sand and refinish a engineered block but most probably come with a long guarantee and need very little maintenance. One advantage with solid is you will be able to sand and re seal as much as you like. If it’s oiled you barely have to sand it.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  13. Dan2223245

    Dan2223245 Active Member

    43
    7
    8
    How long does that take to do 40sqm?

    3-4 days including the for of imagine.
     

    Attached Files:

  14. Dan2223245

    Dan2223245 Active Member

    43
    7
    8
    Solid herringbone is beautiful.

    Cheap lvts look like plastic.

    You pay for something premium and it looks great. We just matched Artselect to a ladies existing real wood floor. You couldn't see a difference in the end product.
     
  15. Rugmunching

    Rugmunching Well-Known Member

    3,679
    630
    113
    I love fitting the art select, black is the most popular for me at the min, alot of my asian customers tend to go dark.
     
  16. merit

    merit Well-Known Member

    8,003
    1,640
    113
    I wasn’t impressed with one of the dark art select boards. Supplied and fitted a hallway for a customer a few years back and their child managed to put a scuff across the pu finish dragging a case across it. They were not happy about it. Same would of happened with a woodfloor but probably not a laminate.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  17. Distinctive Adam

    Distinctive Adam Well-Known Member

    1,692
    497
    83
    Distinctive flooring vintage parquet
     
  18. Dan2223245

    Dan2223245 Active Member

    43
    7
    8
    A scuff or a scratch?

    A scuff normally comes off with the cleaner and an Amtico abrasive pad.

    I think the biggest problem with LVT is when its sold as bulletproof.

    I tell my customers it's not, but it is repairable or easy to replace a plank if required.
     
  19. Rugmunching

    Rugmunching Well-Known Member

    3,679
    630
    113
    I always tell my customers nothing is 100% scratch proof but depends on how they maintain it.
     
  20. Trimmer

    Trimmer Well-Known Member

    1,464
    490
    83
    I prefer engineered prefinished herringbone personally.
    It can be resanded but you save on some of the initial finishing costs.
    Stick down as opposed to floating
     

Share This Page